To Move In… Or Not To Move In – My musings on cohabitation.

This past weekend Jack and I settled onto his couch to watch a movie with an absolutely outstanding bottle of 2005 Majella Sparkling Shiraz (look it up if you want a mouthgasm). About three quarters of the way through the movie we finished the wine and I was feeling great.  When I’m in that state (i.e. drunk and happy) my verbal filter comes right off.  I will say whatever is honestly on my mind.  That night was no different, as I confessed to him that, “I feel like I’m done looking.”  Yikes.  There I go letting shit fly out of my mouth prematurely in this relationship yet again. Thankfully, it didn’t send him running out of his own house just to get away from me.  In fact, he took me upstairs and drove me crazy until we were exhausted, tangled, and falling asleep.

With this new turn of relationship bliss, I’ve been forced to think about how I’d like to see things between us progress.  I meant what I said; for the first time ever I feel like I’m done looking.  I’m not constantly having thoughts of where I’m going next in my dating life.  This relationship is where I feel like I belong.  At most any time of the day, I’d like him to be there, sharing it with me.  So the next step would be a move in, right?  Wrong.

It’s not that I’m uptight or a militant traditional.  There’s a huge part of me that wants nothing more than to cohabitate with Jack.  The other part of me is putting on the breaks. 

Where do my feelings come from?  Well, firstly, I’ve seen numerous live-in relationships dissolve and shit gets messy.  It’s like a divorce without the marriage.  It’s incredibly painful and complicated; I’d say more so than if you break up with someone that you don’t live with.  The possibility of a painful breakup is fairly weak reasoning for not moving in with your partner (I know you were just thinking that), so I’m going to move on to how I think living together has the potential to mess with the psyche of your relationship.

From the conversations I’ve had with advocates of the idea that you need to live with someone before marriage, they believe that when you move in together it is a trial period.  You’re moving in to examine how you fit with the other person in a domestic situation.  You’re looking for the flaws that will drive you nuts if you have to live with them ‘til death do you part.  This means you’re always devoting some mental energy to assessing whether or not things are working.  Basically, living together becomes a secondary audition (initial dating being the first) where the focus is on looking for the fatal flaws, instead of looking for ways to make it work.

And therein lies the issue; I feel like living together can breed a culture wherein at least one party is always looking for reasons it won’t work.   This can then spill over into a marriage when the couple eventually decide to get married.  The couple/individual is still looking to find the cracks but not focusing on ways to fix them.  Shifting away from the mindset of “reasons it won’t work” to “ways to make it work” can be exceptionally difficult.

When I get married I want it to be because my partner and I are both seriously committed to making it work with each other for the rest of our lives.  I don’t want to risk slipping into a mindset where we’re constantly auditioning for each other’s devotion and affection.  Marriage should be a step change in a relationship.  It shouldn’t just be coming home with new rings on your fingers.

I’m all for sleepovers that last for days or weeks, but I’m not going to share an address with you until we’re both ready to make a serious commitment.  Half of the closet and a pledge to try me on for size isn’t going to cut it.

This entry was posted in Romantic (mis)Adventures and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to To Move In… Or Not To Move In – My musings on cohabitation.

  1. TurnJacson says:

    “I feel like living together can breed a culture wherein at least one party is always looking for reasons it won’t work.”

    That kind of attitude isn’t born out of moving in, I think a person that thinks like that… always thinks like that. If both people have agreed, talked about it, and are honest about it… then it shouldn’t be an issue. I think the problem arises when someone moves to accommodate the other person in a relationship and they know they aren’t ready… so they manufacturer a “trial period” as a way out.

    Great Post!

  2. Solo @ 30 says:

    I have “officially” lived with two boyfriends in the past and unofficially with another. Each situation has been different. I haven’t thought about them as “trial runs” for marriage, but I must say the one where we were really fused with a house, cats, families fusing, etc. really felt like a ripping apart divorce when we broke up. We had to divide our “assets”, which included our friends and I had to leave our cats behind.

    Anyway, I actually thinking learning to live with your partner teaches you as much, if not more, about yourself as it does about your partner. That can be incredibly invaluable.

    So happy to hear how well things are going with Jack!

  3. Kelly says:

    I resisted moving in with all of my boyfriends until the last one. I like having my own space…but I think (like you suggested) I wasn’t ready to make that kind of commitment with them. I knew it would end and be messier than if we didn’t live together. I think for some, it helps to live together to figure things out and where the relationship can go. For others, it’s a nervous tightrope walk. Depends on the people and the relationship.

  4. I lived with a serious boyfriend once and I’ll never do it again with out the ring. When Mister Me asked why I told him, unless we’re ready to make the big commitment to each other, there’s no point in making that small one.

    I’m with you.

  5. Charlotte says:

    This is a great post. But I disagree with the commentor above. I lived with my last boyfriend and, well, that relationship went down in flames (to put it nicely, LOL!) but I wouldn’t trade the experience for the world. I think it’s really important to try these things on for size before a wedding comes into the picture. We all have our “things”; best to know what they are before there are surprises after the wedding.

    This is a fantastic post! I am very happy to hear that things are going well with Jack and you’ll know when the timing is right! Best wishes always. XOXO

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s